In a stinging decision, a federal appeals court has ruled the Vermont Principals’ Association clearly discriminated against the Mid Vermont Christian School in Quechee on religious grounds after it opted to forfeit a girls’ playoff basketball game against a high school team with a transgender athlete.
The VPA, in an unprecedented move, banished the Windsor County school in 2023 from its membership after 28 years as a loyal dues-paying and active member. MVCS maintained it was forced to take a forfeit when the VPA refused to consider the school’s protest over safety concerns. Mid Vermont contended the Long Trail School in Dorset was allowing a biologically born boy to play on the girls’ team, court records said.
kAm“%96 D49@@= 36=:6G6D E92E 7@C4:?8 8:C=D E@ 4@>A6E6 282:?DE 3:@=@8:42= >2=6D H@F=5 277:C> E92E E9@D6 >2=6D 2C6 76>2=6D[ 😕 G:@=2E:@? @7 :ED C6=:8:@FD 36=:67D[” E96 &]$] r@FCE @7 pAA62=D 7@C E96 $64@?5 r:C4F:E 😕 }6H *@C< r:EJ D2:5 😕 2 F?2?:>@FD 564:D:@? %F6D52J]k^Am
kAm“(6 4@?4=F56 E92E !=2:?E:77D 2C6 =:<6=J E@ DF44665 😕 D9@H:?8 E92E E96 ‘!p’D 6IAF=D:@? @7 |:5 ‘6C>@?E H2D ?@E ?6FEC2= 3642FD6 :E 5:DA=2J65 9@DE:=:EJ E@H2C5 E96 D49@@=’D C6=:8:@FD 36=:67D[” E96 E9C66\;F586 A2?6= D2:5 😕 :ED CF=:?8]k^Am
kAm%96 ;F586D D2:5 E96J 7@F?5 @A6? 9@DE:=:EJ 3J E96 ‘!p E@H2C5 |:5 ‘6C>@?E r9C:DE:2?] %96 4@FCE 2=D@ ?@E65 E96 ‘!p 72:=65 E@ 7@==@H :ED @H? CF=6D 2?5 A@=:4:6D 😕 :ED CFD9 E@ 5:D>:DD E96 r9C:DE:2? D49@@= 7C@> E96 DE2E6H:56 2DD@4:2E:@?]k^Am
kAm%96 CF=:?8 @G6CEFC?65 2 564:D:@? 3J $6?:@C u656C2= yF586 v6@77C6J (] rC2H7@C5 😕 qFC=:?8E@? E92E 2==@H65 E96 32?:D9>6?E E@ C6>2:? 😕 A=246 H9:=6 E96 EH@ D:56D 32EE=6 😕 4@FCE] %96 42D6 H:== 4@?E:?F6[ 3FE E96 2AA62=D 4@FCE CF=65 E96 D49@@= 42? ?@H A2CE:4:A2E6 😕 ‘!p\DA@?D@C65 6G6?ED]k^Am
kAm“x? DF>[ !=2:?E:77D 2C6 =:<6=J E@ DF44665 😕 6DE23=:D9:?8 E92E s676?52?ED 24E65 H:E9 9@DE:=:EJ E@H2C5 |:5 ‘6C>@?E’D C6=:8:@FD 36=:67D] %96 ‘!p tI64FE:G6 s:C64E@C AF3=:4=J 42DE:82E65 |:5 ‘6C>@?E – 2?5 C6=:8:@FD D49@@=D 86?6C2==J – H9:=6 E96 ‘!p CFD965 E@ ;F58>6?E @? H96E96C 2?5 9@H E@ 5:D4:A=:?6 E96 D49@@=[” E96 ;F586D HC@E6]k^Am
kAm“x? FA9@=5:?8 E96 6IAF=D:@?[ E96 ‘!p 5@F3=65 5@H? @? E92E 9@DE:=:EJ 3J 492==6?8:?8 E96 =68:E:>24J @7 E96 D49@@=’D C6=:8:@FD 36=:67D] p?5 2D ?@E65 23@G6[ E96 AF?:D9>6?E :>A@D65 H2D F?AC64656?E65[ @G6C3C@25 2?5 AC@465FC2==J :CC68F=2C[” E96 ;F586D D2:5 😕 E96 `h\A286 564:D:@?]k^Am
kAm“%9@D6 724ED DEC@?8=J DFAA@CE E96 :?76C6?46 E92E |:5 ‘6C>@?E’D C6=:8:@FD @3;64E:@? H2D ?@E 4@?D:56C65 H:E9 E96 ?6FEC2=:EJ E92E E96 uC66 tI6C4:D6 r=2FD6 C6BF:C6D[” E96J D2:5]k^Am
kAmy2J }:49@=D[ 6I64FE:G6 5:C64E@C @7 E96 ‘!p[ D2:5 %F6D52J 96 H2D F?2H2C6 @7 2?J 2DD@4:2E:@? @77:4:2= @C 6>A=@J66 H9@ 5:D4C:>:?2E65 282:?DE 2?J C6=:8:@FD D49@@=D] w6 DE2E65 E92E 96 H2D AC64=F565 7C@> 255:?8 2?J 7FCE96C 4@>>6?ED 3642FD6 E96 =:E:82E:@? C6>2:?D A6?5:?8]k^Am
kAm%96 ;F586D @C56C65 E96 42D6 D6?E 324< E@ ‘6C>@?E H:E9 :?DECF4E:@?D E@ 8C2?E E96 A=2:?E:77’D >@E:@? 7@C 2 AC6=:>:?2CJ :?;F?4E:@?[ 2==@H:?8 7@C |:5 ‘6C>@?E’D C6:?DE2E6>6?E 2D 2 ‘!p >6>36C]k^Am
kAm|:5 ‘6C>@?E r9C:DE:2? $49@@=[ 7@F?565 😕 `hgf[ 😀 2 AC:G2E6 72:E9\32D65 AC6\z\`a D49@@= 😕 (:?5D@C r@F?EJ[ H9@D6 C6=:8:@FD 36=:67D 5C:G6 2?5 7@C> E96 7@F?52E:@? 7@C 6G6CJE9:?8 :E 5@6D] %96 D49@@= >2:?E2:?D E92E 92G:?8 :ED 8:C=D’ E62> 4@>A6E6 282:?DE 2 >2=6\3@C? 2E9=6E6 H@F=5 92G6 G:@=2E65 E96 D49@@=’D C6=:8:@FD 4@?G:4E:@?D] |’r$ ;@:?65 E96 ‘!p 23@FE `hhb\hc H96? :E 7:6=565 :ED 7:CDE 32D<6E32== E62>]k^Am
kAm%96 t28=6D 92G6 925 D@>6 2E9=6E:4 DF446DD[ :?4=F5:?8 >@DE C646?E=J D92C:?8 E96 s:G:D:@? x’ ‘6C>@?E 9:89 D49@@= 32D<6E32== 4C@H? 😕 a_a_ 😕 2 D62D@? 4FE D9@CE 3J r~’xs] |’r$ W`f\eX @4<65 @77 }@] ` (6DE #FE=2?5 😕 E96 D6>:7:?2=D[ 3FE E96 7:?2= H:E9 !C@4E@C H2D 42==65 @77[ 4C62E:?8 4@\492>AD 7@C E96 7:CDE E:>6]k^Am
kAm|:5 ‘6C>@?E 2?5 EH@ 72>:=:6D[ :?4=F5:?8 r9C:D 2?5 q6E92?J v@@5H:? @7 “F64966[ 7:=65 E96 5:D4C:>:?2E:@? =2HDF:E 282:?DE G2C:@FD DE2E6 2?5 =@42= 65F42E:@? @77:4:2=D 7@C 6IA6==:?8 E96 r9C:DE:2? D49@@= 2?5 :ED DEF56?ED 7C@> E96 DE2E6’D 2E9=6E:4D 2DD@4:2E:@?] (96? E96 =2HDF:E H2D 7:=65 😕 }@G6>36C a_ab[ E96 v@@5H:?D 925 2 D@?[ p]v] [ H9@ H2D @? E96 32D<6E32== 2?5 EC24< E62>D] w:D D:DE6C[ |]v][ H2D 2? 6:89E9 8C256C[ 3FE A=2J65 @? E96 8:C=D’ 32D<6E32== E62>[ C64@C5D D9@H65]k^Am
kAm%96 A=2:?E:77D 2C6 DFAA@CE65 3J %96 p==:2?46 s676?5:?8 uC665@>[ 2 ?2E:@?2==J C64@8?:K65 =2H 7:C> @H? 7@C :ED u:CDE p>6?5>6?E 7:89ED]k^Am
kAm|’r$ @3;64E65 H96? :ED 8:C=D’ G2CD:EJ 32D<6E32== E62> H2D A2:C65 😕 E96 2??F2= DE2E6 E@FC?2>6?E E@ A=2J 2 E62> 7C@> E96 {@?8 %C2:= $49@@= E92E 762EFC65 2 A=2J6C 3@C? 2D 2 3:@=@8:42= 3@J[ 3FE 4=2:>:?8 E@ 36 2 8:C=[ E96 2AA62=D 4@FCE D2:5]k^Am
kAm|:5 ‘6C>@?E 92D D2:5 :E 925 2 D6C:@FD 4@?46C? E92E E96 EC2?D86?56C DEF56?E[ H9@ H2D >@C6 E92? e\766E E2==[ 4C62E65 2? F?D276 2?5 F?72:C D:EF2E:@? 7@C :ED 8:C=D 2D 2 5@>:?2E:?8 >2=6 A=2J6C[ 4@FCE C64@C5D D2:5]k^Am
kAm%96 D49@@= G@=F?E2C:=J 6?565 :ED D62D@? H:E9 2 7@C76:E @? u63] a_[ a_ab] xE D2:5[ 😕 A2CE[ 😕 2 ?6HD C6=62D6 6IA=2:?:?8 E96 564:D:@? E92E “2==@H:?8 3:@=@8:42= >2=6D E@ A2CE:4:A2E6 😕 H@>6?’D DA@CED D6ED 2 325 AC64656?E 7@C E96 7FEFC6 @7 H@>6?’D DA@CED 😕 86?6C2=]”k^Am
kAm%H@ 52JD =2E6C[ }:49@=D E6DE:7:65 367@C6 E96 w@FD6 t5F42E:@? r@>>:EE66 😕 DFAA@CE @7 2 =68:D=2E:G6 3:== E92E H@F=5 AC6G6?E AC:G2E6 C6=:8:@FD D49@@=D 7C@> C646:G:?8 AF3=:4 7F?5:?8] w6 D2:5[ “(6 D9@F=5 ?6G6C AC@G:56 2?J E2I 5@==2CD E@ D49@@=D E92E … =@@< 2H2J 7C@> E96 4@>>@? 5646?4J @7 2== DEF56?ED 36:?8 H6=4@>65]”k^Am
kAmw6 E96? 2EE24<65 D49@@=D E92E 925 4FCC:4F=2 E92E 762EFC6 “r9C:DE:2? G2=F6D[” E96 4@FCE D2:5]k^Am
kAm%9C66 H66@?E 7C@> E96 DE2E6H:56 2DD@4:2E:@? — ?@E ;FDE 32D<6E32== @C DA@CED[ 3FE 2== 6IEC24FCC:4F=2C 24E:G:E:6D] %96 32? 4@G6C65 DA6==:?8 366D[ D4:6?46 72:CD[ 5C2>2 76DE:G2=D 2?5 5632E6 4@>A6E:E:@?D]k^Am
kAm%96 `h\A286 564:D:@? HC:EE6? 7@C E96 4@FCE 3J r:C4F:E yF586 |:4926= w] !2C< E@@< E96 ‘!p 2?5 }:49@=D E@ E2D< 7@C :ED 72:=FC6 E@ 7@==@H :ED @H? AC@465FC6D] w6 H2D ;@:?65 3J yF586D #:492C5 r] (6D=6J 2?5 #:492C5 y] $F==:G2?]k^Am
kAm“%96 6IAF=D:@? G:@=2E65 E96 ‘!p’D @H? ?@C>D] }:49@=D 4@?46565 E92E[ E@ 9:D C64@==64E:@?[ E96 ‘!p 925 ?6G6C 367@C6 32??65 2 D49@@= 7C@> 2== DA@CE:?8 6G6?ED] %92E 4@?46DD:@? 24EF2==J F?56CDE2E65 E96 D6G6C:EJ @7 E96 564:D:@?[ H9:49 6IE6?565 E@ 2?J :?E6CD49@@= 24E:G:EJ[ 7C@> DA6==:?8 366 E@ >2E9 4@>A6E:E:@?D[” E96 4@FCE D2:5]k^Am
kAm“|2<:?8 >2EE6CD H@CD6[ E96 ‘!p :8?@C65 E96 56E2:=65 AC@465FC2= C6BF:C6>6?ED 8@G6C?:?8 :ED 5:D4:A=:?2CJ AC@46DD] %9@D6 AC@465FC6D 42==65 7@C 2 7@C>2= :?G6DE:82E:@?[ 2 AC6=:>:?2CJ C6A@CE[ HC:EE6? ?@E:46 @7 2 AC@323=6 G:@=2E:@?[ 2 C64@>>6?565 A6?2=EJ[ 2?5 2? @AA@CEF?:EJ E@ 36 962C5 2E 2 962C:?8 :?G@=G:?8 4@F?D6= 2?5 6G:56?46] qFE 😕 :ED CFD9 E@ :>A@D6 2? ‘:>>65:2E6’ 6IAF=D:@?[ E96 ‘!p 7=@FE65 :ED @H? CF=6D[” E96 ;F586D D2:5]k^Am
kAm%96J ?@E65 E96 p4E:G:E:6D $E2?52C5D r@>>:EE66 @7 E96 ‘!p >2:?E2:?65 “:E 😀 2 >JE9 E92E EC2?D86?56C DEF56?ED 6?52?86C @E96CD H96? E96J A2CE:4:A2E6 😕 9:89 D49@@= DA@CED @C 4C62E6 F?72:C 4@>A6E:E:@?]”k^Am
kAm%96 ‘!p C68F=2E6D >:55=6 2?5 9:89 D49@@= 6IEC24FCC:4F=2C 24E:G:E:6D 2?5 4@F?ED 2>@?8 :ED >6>36CD 6G6CJ AF3=:4 2?5 AC:G2E6 9:89 D49@@= 😕 E96 DE2E6 2?5 56D4C:36D :ED6=7 2D “2? 25>:?:DEC2E:G6 2C> @7 E96 DE2E6[” E96 ;F586D ?@E65]k^Am
kAm|:5 ‘6C>@?E 4@?E24E65 E96 ‘!p 😕 E96 72== @7 a_ab 23@FE C62AA=J:?8 7@C >6>36CD9:A[ 3FE }:49@=D D2:5 E96 r@>>:EE66’D 564:D:@? 😀 “3:?5:?8” 2?5 “42??@E ?@H 36 492==6?865[” E96 4@FCE ?@E65]k^Am
kAm|’r$ DF3D6BF6?E=J ;@:?65 E96 }6H t?8=2?5 pDD@4:2E:@? @7 r9C:DE:2? $49@@=D[ 3FE E92E 42FD65 2 DF3DE2?E:2= 7:?2?4:2= :?4C62D6 5F6 E@ E:>6 2?5 EC2G6=] %96 =628F6 92D EH@ 5@K6? D49@@=D DAC625 24C@DD 7:G6 DE2E6D]k^Am
kAmpD C646?E=J 2D pF8FDE `c[ 5FC:?8 :ED 2??F2= |65:2 s2J[ E96 ‘!p C6:E6C2E65 :ED DE2?46[ 56DA:E6 2 ?2E:@?2= D9:7E E@H2C5 =:>:E:?8 H@>6?’D DA@CED E@ H@>6?] }:49@=D’ 2DD:DE2?E 7@C DEF56?E 24E:G:E:6D[ {2FC6? *@F?8[ D2:5 E96 ‘!p 2==@HD DEF56?ED E@ A2CE:4:A2E6 32D65 @? 9@H E96J :56?E:7J 2?5 ?@E 3J 3:@=@8J]k^Am
kAmrC2H7@C5 :?:E:2==J 56?:65 2 C6BF6DE 3J E96 !=2:?E:77D 7@C 2 AC6=:>:?2CJ :?;F?4E:@? 😕 yF?6 a_ac] %96J 2AA62=65 2?5 2=D@ C6BF6DE65 2? :?;F?4E:@? A6?5:?8 E96 2AA62=[ 3FE rC2H7@C5 56?:65 :E 282:?]k^Am
kAmxE H2D 2E E92E A@:?E E92E rC2H7@C5 925 BF6DE:@?65 H9J E96 ‘!p H2D @AA@D65 E@ 2==@H:?8 |r’$ DEF56?ED 😕 ?@?\2E9=6E:4 4@>A6E:E:@?D] w6 96=A65 3C@<6C 2 A=2? E92E E96 ‘!p C6=F4E2?E=J 28C665 H:E9 😕 E96 6?5 E@ 2==@H A2CE:4:A2E:@? 😕 ?@?\DA@CED]k^Am
kAmpD E96 42D6 H2D 962565 7@C 2C8F>6?E 😕 pAC:= 😕 }6H *@C< r:EJ[ pEE@C?6J #J2? %F4<6C[ @?6 @7 E96 psu =2HJ6CD E@ 2C8F6 E96 @C:8:?2= 42D6 😕 qFC=:?8E@?[ 24@H=65865 E96 ;F5:4:2= 2?5 A@=:E:42= =2?5D42A6D 925 492?865 😕 E96 AC6G:@FD >@?E9D 2?5 E96 @FE4@>6 >:89E 36 >@C6 72G@C23=6]k^Am
kAm%F4<6C D2:5 E92E >@C6 2?5 >@C6 A6@A=6 H6C6 7F==J F?56CDE2?5:?8 E96 :>A@CE2?46 @7 <66A:?8 8:C=D’ DA@CED 7@C 8:C=D 2?5 DFAA@CE:?8 E96 A@D:E:@? @7 |:5 ‘6C>@?E 2?5 @E96CD 7:89E:?8 E96 32EE=6]k^Am
kAm%96 =2HDF:E H2D :?:E:2==J 7:=65 282:?DE w62E96C q@F496J[ E96?\:?E6C:> D64C6E2CJ @7 E96 ‘6C>@?E p86?4J @7 t5F42E:@?j y6??:76C s64< $2>F6=D@?[ 492:C @7 E96 ‘6C>@?E t5F42E:@? q@2C5[ y2J }:49@=D[ 6I64FE:G6 5:C64E@C @7 E96 ‘!p[ r9C:DE:?6 q@FC?6[ (:?5D@C $@FE962DE $FA6CG:D@CJ &?:@?j E96 w2CE=2?5 $49@@= q@2C5[ #2?52== v2H6=[ D49@@= DFA6C:?E6?56?E 7@C E96 ~C2?86 t2DE $FA6CG:D@CJ &?:@?[ 2?5 E96 (2:ED #:G6C ‘2==6J $49@@= q@2C5]k^Am
kAm+@:6 $2F?56CD[ E96 ?6H $64C6E2CJ @7 t5F42E:@? 7@C v@G] !9:= $4@EE[ 😀 ?@H 2 ?2>65 5676?52?E C6A=24:?8 q@F496J 😕 E96 =2HDF:E]k^Am
kAm%96 =2HDF:E >2:?E2:?D E96C6 😀 :CC6A2C23=6 92C>[ :?4=F5:?8 7:?2?4:2=[ E92E E96 ‘!p 2?5 p~t 92G6 :?7=:4E65 @? E96 |:5 ‘6C>@?E r9C:DE:2? DEF56?ED 2?5 E96:C 72>:=:6D]k^Am
kAm%96 =2HDF:E D66A6?D2E:@? 7@C 52>286D :?7=:4E65]k^Am
kAmp D64@?5 D6E @7 A2C6?ED 2?5 E96:C EH@ 49:=5C6? 7C@> }@CE9 w2CE=2?5 H6C6 2=D@ A2CE @7 E96 :?:E:2= 7656C2= =2HDF:E[ 3FE H:E95C6H 3642FD6 E96 42D6 5C28865 @?]k^Am
kAm%96 >@E96C C6A@CE65 E96J H6C6 >@G:?8 E96:C 49:=5C6? E@ 2 }6H w2>AD9:C6 9:89 D49@@= 7@C >F=E:A=6 C62D@?D[ :?4=F5:?8 96C D@? H2?E65 E@ A=2J 7@@E32== E96 ?6IE J62C]k^Am
kAmw6 H@F=5 92G6 ?@C>2==J 366? 23=6 E@ ;@:? 2 =@42= ‘6C>@?E 9:89 D49@@= 7@@E32== E62> 😕 E96 ‘!p’D “>6>36C E@ >6>36C” AC@8C2>[ :7 |:5 ‘6C>@?E 925 ?@E 366? 32??65 3J E96 2DD@4:2E:@?[ D96 D2:5]k^Am
